• 0 Posts
  • 271 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 14th, 2023

help-circle




  • The fediverse has a built-in search engine?

    I can only comment on my experience searching for communities in lemmy and people to follow on mastadon, but in both cases I am not sure I’d say “works quite well” would describe my experience.

    But also that’s not what I think OP was talking about.

    They want a search engine for a random fact like google. It’s been long true that you need to add “reddit” to the end of any google search to find the info you needed.

    It’d be nice to have a fediverse alternative.









  • While Helldivers 2 and Baldur’s Gate 3 might look like sudden jackpot successes

    This article is funny. It’s like the feel-good inverse of a rage-bait article. It’s stating what we all want to be true and cherry-picking two games that only sort of provide evidence towards it, and only if you squint really hard.

    Both games are sequels backed by huge publishers with tons of cash.

    BG3 is a Dungeons and Dragons franchise title; a franchise which recently received a massively successful film, a huge boost in popularity during a pandemic, and a boost in cultural relevance in Strange Things.

    Helldivers 2 fits the claim a bit better, but it is still a sequel to a well received, well selling title. The extraction shooter genre is also exceedingly popular right now, and the fact that it has Games as a Service bullshit built in says that publishers weren’t as hands-off as the article implies.

    So the more realistic take-away from this is that good games with huge budgets for development AND marketing in reasonably popular genres can make a ton of money.

    Which isn’t saying much. And it certainly doesn’t look like a sudden jackpot.


  • I don’t know the answer but they pointed this out further in the press release:

    However, it’s also important for us that Mastodon is one of the few, if not the only social media platform that operates out of the EU, and we would like to keep it that way.

    I’d assume that this is for a reason, too. If it were advantageous to run your company out of the EU people would probably do so sometimes.


  • You are describing the current situation in the fediverse, not a problem caused by the idea proposed.

    Allowing for federated identity would also imply allowing migration of identity, which wholly prevents what you just described.

    The current system is guaranteed to have larger instances where people won’t want to leave because doing so abandons your identity.

    If I could move around the fediverse freely I would do so, but that is not a feature that is supported so I stick to the largest instance which happens to be the one I chose. I am not unique in this. Obviously, or this instance wouldn’t be so large.

    Offering federated identity is only a better situation than today.


  • Imagine if login was a federated feature in lemmy.

    What this would mean is that I could go to lemmy.ml and login using my lemmy.world account credentials and people from lemmy.ml could go to lemmy.world and log in using theirs.

    Neither could go to beehaw and login because it does not federate with the two of them.

    In this world I could create an identity on lemmy.world and a separate identity on lemmy.ml if I wanted to.

    Now imagine if I could login with my lemmy.world account on a non lemmy platform that lemmy.world federates with.

    There’s nothing centralized about this, and it is exactly in the spirit of everything else in the fediverse. To login on beehaw I would have to create an identity on beehaw or someone they federate with.

    What you seem to be against is forcing you to have only one login. That does go against the model we are talking about.

    And it isn’t what’s being suggested.


  • Nothing about this idea implies centralization. There is no reason identity has to be tied to the platform using the identity and no reason why there needs to be a central identity store.

    In fact, right now my identity IS centralized to lemmy.world and I have no control over that.

    Your solution to create as many identities as you want is great for avoiding having one identity, but not an example of decentralized identity.

    I would like to be able to have multiple, decentralized, identities.